It hides in bread, pasta and cookies: is this ingredient worse than sugar?

It hides in bread, pasta and cookies: is this ingredient worse than sugar?
We watch sugar, we limit desserts… but we sometimes forget an ingredient that is omnipresent on our plates: white flour. According to Dr Pierre Dukan, its impact on blood sugar could be even more significant. A nutritionist qualifies this statement and explains what really matters.

The enemy is not who we think. In a video that has now gone viral on Instagram, Dr Pierre Dukan claims that an ingredient even more problematic than sugar for blood sugar levels is hidden in our everyday plates. And that culprit is… white flour.

White flour, “sweeter” than we think

Bread, pasta, pancakes, biscuits, sauces… it’s hard to escape. However, according to the expert, the glycemic index (GI) of white flour can climb up to 85, compared to 70 for white sugar. In other words: weight equal, white flour would raise blood sugar levels even more quickly than sugar itself.

Nothing to be happy about when you prepare a “homemade” cake thinking it’s better than the industrial versions. And the observation does not stop there: flaked purees, breakfast cereals, or even white breads intended for children also display very high GIs. Result: an express burst of energy followed by a big bout of fatigue.

But is it really fair to say that white flour is “worse than sugar”?

“It’s a shortcut,” replies nutritionist Eva Vacheau

Contacted on the subject, nutritionist Eva Vacheau thinks on the contrary that this statement deserves to be qualified:

“To say that white flour is worse than sugar is a shortcut. The glycemic index of white flour is indeed higher, but it all depends on the refining, the quantity consumed and the context of the meal.”

Of course, white flour is completely refined: devoid of fiber, vitamins and minerals, it passes very quickly into the blood, hence the rapid rise in blood sugar levels.

But the expert insists: the real impact does not depend only on an isolated food.

“What matters is the glycemic load of the meal ‘as a whole’. A piece of white baguette alone will increase blood sugar, but accompanied by vegetables (fiber) and proteins, the effect is much more moderate.”

Flour or sugar: not a “worst student” competition

So, should we ban flour and sugar from our cupboards? Not really. According to Eva Vacheau, both can be problematic, but not for the same reasons:

  • White sugar, consumed in excess, causes chronic inflammation, oxidative stress and can lead to insulin resistance, or even non-alcoholic fatty liver;
  • White flour acts mainly through its rapid effect on blood sugar and its lack of protective nutrients.

“It’s not a contest of which is worse or better. Both, consumed in excess and in isolation, are problematic”decides the nutritionist.

Smarter alternatives

The nutritionist also reminds us that options are available to us when it comes to flours. Some are much more beneficial for health, including rye, spelled, buckwheat or even barley flour.

“These “old” flours have a lower glycemic index, more fiber, more nutrients, and often less gluten than modern wheat”
she adds.

But in the end, there is no need to put these two ingredients back to back which are difficult to do without completely.
“What matters is the overall context of the meal, the quality of the food and the diversity of carbohydrate sources.”

So, instead of banning sugar or flour, it’s better to relearn how to combine them intelligently. A little white bread? Why not, but with a nice portion of vegetables and a source of protein on the side.

FAQ – White flour vs sugar: which is really worse?

1. Why does white flour raise blood sugar levels so much?

Because it is refined and low in fiber. Result: it quickly transforms into glucose in the blood. Its glycemic index can even exceed that of sugar. To limit this peak, it can be consumed with fiber or protein, which slows absorption.

2. Should we completely ban white flour?

No. It is not an “enemy” to eliminate, but an ingredient to balance. In small quantities and in a complete meal, its impact remains moderate. The important thing is the overall glycemic load and the variety of carbohydrate sources.

3. What are the best alternatives to white flour?

Rye, spelled, barley or buckwheat flours are richer in fiber and nutrients. Their glycemic index is lower and they fill you up better. They are also suitable for those looking to reduce gluten without eliminating it completely.