
A freedom that questions: why do we take pleasure in doing virtually what we forbid ourselves in reality? Should we see it as a way of expressing aggressive impulses, of enjoying a form of omnipotence or simply of escaping from everyday life? And above all, can this virtual violence constitute an outlet without consequences?
For psychologist Amélie Boukhobza interviewed by True Medical, a distinction is essential: taking pleasure in virtually transgressing prohibitions does not mean wanting to violate them in real life.
GTA 6: why do we like to break the rules so much?
Steal a car, sow chaos in a city, defy the authorities… In GTA, the possibilities of transgression fully participate in the pleasure of the game. But this attraction to prohibited behavior does not necessarily reflect a fascination for real violence.
“Be careful not to confuse the pleasure of transgressing with the desire to actually commit the acts that you portray. Because you can perfectly enjoy stealing a car in GTA without having the slightest desire to steal one in real life. Fortunately, anyway!“, recalls the psychologist.
What makes the experience attractive is in particular the possibility of freeing oneself, for the duration of a game, from the usual constraints. In daily life, our behavior is governed by social rules, obligations and the need to take into account the consequences of our actions. In the game, this reality is turned upside down.
“The game creates a space in which the usual rules are suspended. In daily life, we are constantly confronted with prohibitions, obligations, constraints. We must control our behavior, anticipate their consequences, take others into account. And now a game offers exactly the opposite! It’s great!”
This freedom can also provide a feeling of omnipotence. The player decides his actions, explores an immense environment and intervenes in what surrounds him. He thus regains a form of control that he does not necessarily possess in his daily life.
However, it would be simplistic to explain this attraction by the presence of hidden violent impulses. Fiction also allows us to explore situations and emotions without wishing to actually experience them. “We also like horror films without wanting to be chased by a killer. You can be fascinated by a criminal character in a series without approving of his actions“, illustrates the specialist.
It also evokes, from a psychoanalytic point of view, a space in which certain desires, fantasies or aggressive movements can find a form of representation. But this does not mean that every virtual behavior reveals an unconscious desire to take action.
Finally, violence alone does not explain the pleasure of playing GTA. Missions, challenges, humor, exploration and story also add to the experience. “What can be particularly attractive in a game like GTA is being able to play with the forbidden while knowing that we remain in a fictional universe.“, summarizes the psychologist.
Playing GTA to let off steam: does video games really allow you to vent your anger?
This is an argument often put forward by fans of violent video games: after a difficult day, a game of GTA would allow you to release the pressure, let off steam and leave behind the annoyances of everyday life. This idea is based on the notion of catharsis, according to which expressing one’s aggression would allow one to free oneself from it.
But this explanation deserves to be qualified. “So here, I would be very careful with the idea of catharsis“, warns the psychologist. According to her, we must in particular be wary of the image of aggression which accumulates inside us and which we simply need to unload to get better.
Indeed, a player can perfectly feel peaceful after an hour spent on GTA. But that doesn’t necessarily mean that virtually hitting or killing characters allowed him to vent his anger.
“But what exactly made him feel good? Is it the fact of having virtually hit or killed someone? Or just the fact of having had fun, of having disconnected as they say, of having been absorbed by an activity, of having stopped thinking about your problems, of having rediscovered a feeling of freedom or mastery? It’s not the same thing at all“, she emphasizes.
Video games can actually help regulate emotions, allowing you to distract yourself, distance yourself from your concerns and find pleasure again. But this well-being should not be confused with a reduction in aggressiveness.
Moreover, the psychologist recalls that research does not allow us to affirm that the staging of violent behavior in a video game permanently reduces aggression. Conversely, it would be just as excessive to consider that playing at killing virtual characters necessarily makes you violent in real life.
Some studies observe associations between violent video games and certain indicators of aggression, while others do not find these effects. It is also important to distinguish between temporary irritation, aggressive thoughts and real violent behavior: these phenomena are not equivalent.
In other words, feeling better after a game of GTA does not necessarily mean having let go of your violence.
The benefit felt can simply be linked to the pleasure of the game, the distraction or the feeling of momentarily regaining control.
GTA 6: when can video games become problematic?
Should we be concerned that a teenager enjoys playing a criminal character, stealing cars or committing violent acts in GTA? Not necessarily. For the psychologist, it is essential not to confuse the behaviors represented in a game and the values or intentions of the player.
“A player does not have a psychological problem just because he likes GTA or because he enjoys committing violent acts in it. This would be a completely wrong shortcut.“, she insists.
The possible effects of video gaming depend on many factors: age, maturity, family environment, psychological vulnerabilities, the context in which we play, but also the place that gaming occupies in life.
However, special attention can be paid to adolescents. Understanding intellectually that a scene is fictional does not necessarily mean being able to take the same emotional distance. Not all young people have the same maturity or the same emotional regulation skills.
Beyond the content of the game, it is also the way in which the young person understands and integrates it which deserves to be taken into account.
The psychologist especially invites parents to observe possible changes in behavior. A teenager who gradually isolates himself, neglects relationships, activities or sleep, or becomes particularly irritable when he cannot play may deserve special attention.
Another signal to watch for: when gaming becomes the only way to support your emotions or escape the difficulties of everyday life. “And above all, does he retain any freedom in relation to this activity? It’s essential“, she recalls.
The duration of play is therefore not enough, on its own, to determine whether a practice is problematic. “We can play a lot without being in pathological use. Conversely, you can play for less time, but in a way that becomes problematic if you lose control of your practice and it has significant consequences in your life.“, she explains.
Finally, if a young person already displays violent behavior, significant difficulties with empathy or psychological suffering, it may be relevant to take an interest in all of their experiences, including their digital practices. Without making the video game responsible for all its difficulties.
Ultimately, GTA 6 is neither a psychological release nor a game that would make you violent. The challenge is rather to understand what the player is looking for in this universe, what he finds there and the place that this experience takes in his real life.