
A new step in the implementation of assisted dying
When a seriously ill person considers assisted dying, the questions go well beyond the medical framework. They affect autonomy, dignity, freedom to choose and the place of loved ones in the last moments of life.
It is in this context that the High Authority for Health (HAS) published, on November 19, 2026, its recommendations entitled “Lethal substances for assisted dying and conditions of administration”.
Their objective: to define the substances likely to be used, to regulate their prescription and administration and to specify the action to be taken in the event of difficulty, failure or complication.
However, a distinction is essential: these recommendations do not modify the legal conditions of access to assisted dyingset by the law of August 18, 2026. They occur once the request has been examined and accepted.
The system concerns in particular adults, French or residing in a stable and regular manner in France, suffering from a serious and incurable condition affecting their vital prognosis in the advanced or terminal phase. The request must also meet the legal criteria concerning suffering and the capacity to express a free and informed will.
The HAS therefore does not decide who can benefit from this right. It specifies how professionals must supervise its implementation.
But it is when the procedure does not go as planned that its recommendations raise the most sensitive questions.
What happens when the procedure fails?
French law favors the administration of the substance by the person themselves, when their physical condition allows it. A doctor or nurse can intervene directly when the person is not physically able to carry out the administration themselves. But what if she loses consciousness before death occurs?
The HAS provides for several additional protocols. In certain situations, the healthcare professional may have to intervene himself to continue the procedure, particularly when the initial administration has failed.
It is precisely this point that worries the Democracy, Ethics and Solidarity Collective (CDES). In his note published on November 19, he highlights a major difficulty: the person may no longer be able to confirm their wishes, clarify them or reverse their decision. The collective believes that these additional interventions raise a legal question, in relation to the strict supervision of the situations described by the law.
In a joint press release, the heads of the organizations (French Society for Support and Palliative Care, SNPI, CFE CGC, Afsos, SMP) underline that: “The HAS recommendations illustrate several warning points that the signatory organizations have noted in recent months, starting with the difficult operational distinction between self-administration and hetero-administration. This difficulty is reinforced by the total absence of precision on “physical incapacity”, a criterion theoretically allowing the mode of administration to be determined..
Beyond the legal debate, a question remains: how can we guarantee respect for a person’s wishes when they are no longer conscious and can therefore no longer express themselves?
Patients, relatives and caregivers: other issues of the protocol
For the person concerned, the prospect of a complication, a longer than expected delay or an additional intervention can weigh on the days preceding the procedure. Control over one’s last moments then becomes a central question.
The CDES requires detailed prior information, as well as written and revocable consent on the action to be taken in the event of a complication. The collective also wants the person to be able to rule out in advance any additional intervention carried out by a third party.
Relatives are also affected. The HAS provides for an indicative presence of the healthcare professional of three hours for oral administration and 90 minutes for intravenous administration. However, these durations do not guarantee that death will occur within this period. Recommendation R60 mentions in particular the possibility, in rare situations, of a prolonged interval between respiratory arrest and cardiac arrest, likely to be accompanied by visible changes in physical appearance.
For the CDES, families must be better prepared for these eventualities. The collective asks that they be informed of what they could see, free to attend the procedure or not and assured of not having to monitor its progress or make a medical decision.
Finally, healthcare professionals may be faced with particularly difficult situations, particularly when they have to intervene when the person has lost consciousness. The collective warns of the moral burden and legal uncertainties likely to weigh on doctors and nurses. He calls for guarantees: volunteering, specific training, ethical and psychological support and the possibility of debriefing after the procedure.
The same concern is expressed by the signatories of the joint press release: “Furthermore, the very strong integration of caregivers in the process poses a risk of confusion between the palliative support process and the assisted dying procedure. The signatory organizations will remain extremely vigilant in safeguarding the philosophy of palliative care and real access for all patients to care, particularly analgesic, medico-psychological and generally linked to chronic pathologies.”.
Human guarantees still at the heart of the debate
HAS states that it wants to reconcile medical safety and respect for individuals. She recommends that “the whole process leads to a peaceful death of the person” (recommendation R1, November 2026).
But several practical and ethical questions remain raised by the organizations signing the press release and by the CDES. The latter requires in particular that situations of failure be the subject of feedback, in order to measure the consequences on patients, their loved ones and caregivers.
The publication of the HAS constitutes an important step in the application of the law. It gives professionals benchmarks to guide a new practice. But it also reminds us that assisted dying cannot be reduced to a succession of technical gestures.
The challenge now is to guarantee that the wishes of the person, their information and their support remain at the center of the system, including when the procedure does not go as planned.