Poultry ham or white ham? Dr. Jean-Michel Cohen breaks the myth of “healthy” cold cuts

Poultry ham or white ham? Dr. Jean-Michel Cohen breaks the myth of “healthy” cold cuts
Poultry ham is often seen as a lighter option than white ham. However, Dr Jean-Michel Cohen warns against this preconceived idea. Discover the nutritional differences between these two types of ham.

Poultry ham may be a little less fatty than white ham, but it does not necessarily become a “healthy” cold meat. In a video published on Instagram, the Dr Jean-Michel Cohen account recalls that the difference is mainly moderate: the real criterion remains the label, in particular the salt, and the frequency of consumption.

A little less fatty, but not a separate food

In his video, the account Dr Jean-Michel Cohen summarizes the principle well: poultry ham takes the idea of ​​ham, but with poultry meat rather than pork. He also emphasizes a useful point to put the “light” image of the product into perspective: the energy values ​​are close to those of white ham.

The average nutritional data points in this direction. According to the Anses Ciqual 2020 table, chicken ham and defatted de-rinded white ham are in close orders of magnitude for calories and proteins. Chicken ham appears on average a little less rich in lipids
and saturated fatty acids, but the difference does not transform the product into the equivalent of fresh, unprocessed poultry.

This is the essential nuance: poultry ham remains a cold meat. In French nutritional guidelines, it is ranked with cold meats, in the same way as white ham. In other words, it should not be confused with a home-cooked chicken breast or a turkey escalope.

The account Dr Jean-Michel Cohen also formulates a fairly cautious conclusion on daily choice:

“Frankly, it’s a matter of taste or a matter of obligation.”

This remark is important: choosing poultry ham can respond to a taste preference, a dietary habit or a personal constraint. But on a nutritional level alone, the difference with a lean white ham remains limited. To deepen the comparison, True Medical also reminds us that white ham remains a lean but salty cold meat.

The real reflex: compare the label and limit the frequency

The most misleading point often concerns salt. In the video, poultry ham is presented as less salty. But this idea should not be generalized: the contents vary depending on the brands, recipes and ranges, particularly the reduced salt versions. The right reflex is therefore simple: look at the “salt” line on the labelrather than assuming that a poultry product is automatically better.

To choose more calmly at the supermarket, a few practical guidelines are enough:

  • Compare salt per 100 g between two products actually available on the shelves;
  • Look at lipids and saturated fatty acids if the goal is to choose the least fatty option;
  • Do not just rely on the word “poultry”, because it is still a processed meat;
  • Consider portion and frequencynot just numbers per 100 g.

This last point matters as much as the choice between pork and poultry. The National Nutrition and Health Program recommends limiting all cold meats to 150 g per week, or approximately three slices of white ham or poultry ham. This benchmark does not mean that these foods must be banned, but that they must remain occasional in the overall balance of the diet.

We must also avoid frequent confusion between nutritional comparison and guaranteed health benefits. The fact that a poultry ham is sometimes less fatty is a compositional characteristic; this does not prove that it reduces a risk of disease compared to all white hams. The World Health Organization and the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classify processed meats as carcinogenic to humans based on evidence including colorectal cancer. This classification concerns the level of scientific proofnot an individual prediction nor a direct comparison between each type of ham.

In practice, poultry ham can therefore be an interesting option if its label is favorable and if you like its taste. But the best choice remains the one that combines
less salt, clear composition and moderate consumption. To go further on the shelf selection criteria, you can consult the guidelines for choosing the right ham in the supermarket.